A combi boiler heats water on demand directly from the mains and suits most homes with one or two bathrooms. A system boiler works alongside a hot water storage cylinder to serve homes with more bathrooms or heavy hot water use. A regular boiler, also called a heat only or conventional boiler, uses a cylinder and a cold water tank in the loft and suits older systems or areas with low mains pressure. Choosing the right type is the first step before looking at prices.
The three main types of boiler
There are three main ways to heat a UK home using gas. Each setup uses different parts and handles water in a completely different way. The choice comes down to how much hot water you use at once, the strength of your mains water pressure, and how much space you have.
If you are reading this because your current boiler has broken down in winter, your priority is to limit any damage first. Turn off your heating, switch off the electricity at the mains if water is near electrics and it is safe to reach, and catch any leaking water before you start researching replacements.
You do not necessarily have to stick with the type you already have. Many homeowners choose to switch types when they upgrade, often to save space or to get a better shower pressure. However, changing the type of boiler you have is a much bigger job than swapping a unit directly for the exact same kind.
Knowing the difference between the types means you can have an honest conversation with the installer about what your home actually needs. You can ask the right questions about water pressure and space rather than just accepting a like-for-like swap.
How a combi boiler works
A combi boiler is a single compact unit that provides both your central heating and your hot water. It takes cold water directly from the mains supply pipe and heats it on demand. When you turn on a hot tap, a sensor inside the boiler detects the water flowing and fires up the burner to heat it instantly.
Because a combi boiler heats water exactly when you need it, there is no need for a hot water storage cylinder in an airing cupboard. You also do not need a cold water storage tank in the loft. This makes a combi a great space saver for smaller homes.
Water comes straight from the mains, so you get a strong shower pressure as long as your incoming mains water pressure is good. You also never run out of hot water, no matter how long you run the shower or run the bath.
The main downside is that a combi boiler can struggle when several outlets run at the same time. If someone turns on the kitchen tap while you are in the shower, the flow of water will drop. A combi depends entirely on the strength of your mains water pressure to push water around the house.
How a system boiler works
A system boiler heats your radiators directly but works with a separate hot water storage cylinder to provide hot water to your taps. It takes its cold water supply directly from the mains. Because it uses the mains pressure, it usually does not need a cold water storage tank in the loft.
The boiler heats the water and pumps it through a coil inside the hot water cylinder. This coil heats the stored water around it, keeping it hot and ready for when you open a tap. Because the hot water is already stored and waiting, a system boiler and cylinder can often supply several outlets more effectively at times of heavy demand.
System boilers are also compatible with solar panels if you want to heat your water using renewable energy. The main parts, such as the pump and the expansion vessel, are built into the boiler casing itself.
The disadvantage is that you need a dedicated space for the hot water cylinder. You also lose some heat from the stored water over time, even with a well-insulated cylinder. Once the cylinder is fully empty, you have to wait for the boiler to heat a fresh batch of water.
How a regular boiler works
A regular boiler is also known as a heat only or conventional boiler. It is the oldest and most traditional style of central heating. A regular boiler setup has three main parts to make the heating and hot water work.
- The boiler unit itself which heats the water for the house.
- A separate hot water storage cylinder, usually kept in an airing cupboard.
- A cold water storage tank which is typically kept up in the loft.
This setup relies heavily on gravity. The cold water tank in the loft feeds water down to the cylinder below it. It is often the best choice for areas with very low mains water pressure, where a combi would not have enough force to work properly.
Regular boilers also suit older heating systems where the old radiator pipework might leak under the higher pressure of a sealed combi or system boiler. Like a system boiler, it copes well when multiple taps run at once. The drawbacks are the large amount of space needed for both a cylinder and loft tanks, and the fact that water pressure upstairs can be poor because it relies solely on gravity.
Which type suits your home
Your household hot water demand is the biggest factor in deciding which boiler type to install. If you live in a small or average-sized home with one bathroom, a combi boiler is the clear choice. An average-sized home with two bathrooms can also usually run comfortably on a combi, provided your mains water pressure is strong.
If you live in a large home with two bathrooms, or an average-sized home with three or more bathrooms, a system or regular boiler is usually the better fit. These setups store hot water in advance, so they can often serve several showers running at the same time more effectively than a combi.
Your choice also depends on your water pressure and whether you have loft space. System boilers usually work with unvented cylinders. These unvented cylinders are fully sealed and take water directly from the mains, giving a higher and more consistent flow with no need for a loft tank.
Homes with low mains pressure should avoid unvented cylinders because the flow will be too weak. If your mains pressure is poor, you will need a vented cylinder instead. Vented cylinders are fed from a cold water tank, typically placed in the loft, and rely entirely on gravity to push the water down to your taps and showers.
For a vented system to work properly, you need enough loft space to fit the tank, and the tank must be placed high enough to create enough gravity. If you need details on the costs of changing the cylinder itself, you can read about replacing a hot water cylinder.
What size boiler do you need?
Boiler size is measured in kilowatts (kW) and tells you how powerful the burner inside the boiler is. You need enough power to run all your radiators in the winter and heat your hot water. Combi boilers need a higher kW rating than system or regular boilers because they have to heat cold mains water instantly as it flows through the pipes.
The table below gives a rough guide to the boiler sizes typically needed for different homes. It shows how the power required changes depending on the type of boiler you choose.
|
Home size and radiators |
Combi boiler size |
System or regular boiler size |
|---|---|---|
|
1 bathroom, 1 to 2 bedrooms, up to 10 radiators |
24 to 27kW |
12 to 18kW |
|
2 bathrooms, 3 to 4 bedrooms, 10 or more radiators |
28 to 34kW |
18 to 26kW |
|
3 or more bathrooms, 4 or more bedrooms, 20 or more radiators |
35 to 42kW |
27 to 40kW |
These are rough published sizing figures, and the right size for your home depends on its heat loss and hot water demand. For homes with three or more bathrooms, a system boiler is often a much better choice than fitting a very large combi.
Do not be tempted to buy a bigger boiler than you need just to be on the safe side. An oversized boiler frequently cycles on and off, uses more energy than needed and wears out faster. This leads to higher upfront and running costs.
The correct way to size a boiler is for the installer to carry out a full heat loss calculation. They will measure your rooms, check your insulation and look at your hot water demand. The installer should always confirm the final size based on this heat loss calculation.
What condensing means
Many people think a condensing boiler is a separate type of boiler, but it is actually a specific technology. A condensing boiler captures waste heat from the hot flue gases that would normally escape outside through the flue pipe. It uses this captured heat to help warm the water returning from your central heating system.
Because the boiler extracts so much heat from the waste gases, the water vapour in them condenses into a mildly acidic liquid. This liquid is drained away safely through a plastic condensate pipe. Almost all modern boilers use this technology to save energy and lower heating bills.
Most gas and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) boilers installed after 2005 are condensing. The same rule applies to oil boilers installed after 2007.
If you are fitting a new or replacement gas boiler in an English home, it must meet a minimum ErP efficiency of 92%. Condensing technology is exactly what allows modern boilers to reach this strict legal standard.
If your home is off the gas grid, you might look at oil or LPG boilers, which also come in combi, system and regular versions. For smaller properties without gas, an electric boiler is a clean option. You can read more about what an electric boiler costs to see if one suits your home.
Switching from one type to another
Replacing your boiler with the same type is usually the cheapest and fastest option. A like-for-like combi replacement typically costs £2,000 to £3,500. A like-for-like system boiler ranges from £2,200 to £4,000, and a regular boiler ranges from £2,300 to £4,500.
Converting from a regular or system boiler to a combi is a much larger and more disruptive job. This conversion typically costs £3,500 to £5,500. The higher price covers the extra labour and materials needed to change the way your home handles water.
The work involves removing the old boiler and taking out the hot water cylinder. The installer also has to remove or decommission the old cold water storage tanks in the loft. Pipework under the floorboards often has to be altered to connect your new combi boiler directly to the incoming mains supply pipe.
Before switching, the installer must check that your mains water supply can deliver enough pressure and flow. You can read a full breakdown of what pushes these prices up or down when pricing a new boiler installation.
Rules and protections for boiler installation
By law, anyone employed to work on gas appliances in homes must be a Gas Safe registered engineer. They must also be fully competent in the specific type of gas work they are doing. DIY gas work of any kind is strictly illegal and highly dangerous.
Every registered engineer carries a Gas Safe ID card showing exactly which types of appliance they are qualified to work on. You can check their registration by calling the Gas Safe Register on 0800 408 5500, by checking their official website, or by texting Gas plus the engineer's seven digit licence number to 85080.
The Health and Safety Executive strongly advises that all gas appliances, flues and pipework are installed, maintained and serviced at least annually by a Gas Safe registered engineer. If you are a landlord, you must arrange an annual gas safety check and give a copy of the record to your tenants.
In England, a new or replacement boiler must also be notified to a building control body, regardless of the fuel type. Your registered installer should notify the local authority through their competent person scheme. They will then give you a certificate of compliance with the Building Regulations, which you should receive within 30 days of the work being completed.
Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, a service must be carried out with reasonable care and skill. You can ask for poor work to be put right at no extra cost. Services arranged by phone, online or at your home usually carry a 14-day cooling-off period, though this does not automatically apply to urgent repairs you have asked for. You can contact Citizens Advice for full guidance on these consumer rights.
Questions to ask your installer
When you invite heating engineers to quote for a new boiler, asking the right questions helps you compare their advice fairly. A trustworthy tradesperson will be happy to explain their reasoning and show you their credentials.
A proper quote is a fixed price for the whole job. An estimate is only a rough guess and can increase later. Ask these specific questions when the installer visits your home to ensure you get a full written quote.
- Have you carried out a proper heat loss calculation to size the new boiler correctly?
- How many hot water outlets must the boiler serve at once, and can this model handle it?
- What is my mains water pressure and flow rate, and is it strong enough for a combi?
- Will the existing hot water cylinder and loft tanks be removed entirely or left in place?
- Does the fixed price quote include VAT, parts, materials and extras like a magnetic filter?
- Are you Gas Safe registered, and does your ID card cover this specific type of appliance?
- Will you notify the local authority for Building Regulations and provide the compliance certificate?
- What records do I need to keep to ensure the manufacturer's warranty remains valid?
Common questions
What is a heat only boiler?
A heat only boiler is just another name for a regular or conventional boiler. It provides heat for your radiators directly, but it relies on a separate hot water storage cylinder and a cold water tank in the loft to provide hot water to your taps.
Is a conventional boiler better than a combi?
A conventional boiler is often better if you have a large home with several bathrooms, or if your mains water pressure is too low to run a combi. A combi is generally better for smaller homes because it frees up space by removing the need for a cylinder and loft tanks.
Will an oversized boiler heat my home faster?
Not usually. An oversized boiler tends to heat the water quickly, switch itself off and then fire up again shortly afterwards. This constant cycling wastes energy, increases your running costs and causes the internal boiler parts to wear out prematurely.
Can I keep my hot water cylinder with a new boiler?
You can keep your hot water cylinder if you are installing a new system or regular boiler, provided the cylinder is still in good condition. If you are switching to a combi boiler, the cylinder is usually removed, because a combi heats water directly from the mains on demand and does not normally need one.
What to do next
Before you contact a heating engineer for quotes, take a few minutes to check your current setup. Understanding what you already have makes it much easier to explain the job over the phone.
- Count how many bathrooms you have and think about how often the showers or taps are used at the exact same time.
- Check your current boiler type by looking for a hot water cylinder in an airing cupboard and a cold water tank in the loft.
- Decide whether you want to stick with your current boiler type or pay the extra conversion costs to change it.
- Write down any problems with your current water pressure so you can discuss them with the installer.
- Gather three fixed price written quotes from Gas Safe registered engineers who have carried out a proper heat loss calculation.
When you are ready to get quotes and check the options for your home, you can find a plumber near you to inspect your current system and talk through the best boiler type for your needs.
Find a top rated plumber near you
4,869 plumbers across the UK, each ranked on their Google rating and the number of reviews behind it. Start with your county: